Goldman Sachs Trader “Revisits the 2018 Playbook”: Still Clearly Remembers “On December 24th, Clients Asked Why the Market Dropped So Much—And I Had No Idea”
Brian Garrett pointed out that the current adjustment in the US stock market is similar to the sharp decline in Q4 2018: the S&P 500 has already experienced 42% of the corresponding drop, and the VIX is approaching its peak just before Christmas. If history repeats itself, the bottom of this cycle may appear in January next year. However, the credit market and Federal Reserve policy have yet to provide clear signals of a bottom.
US stocks have fallen for seven consecutive days. Goldman Sachs derivatives traders warn that the market is exhibiting similarities to the sharp sell-off in the fourth quarter of 2018, and the current correction may not be over yet.
Goldman Sachs derivatives strategist Brian Garrett noted in a report released on Friday that the current market trend, technicals, and trading structures all show significant similarities to 2018. By comparing the index declines from both cycles, he assesses the potential further downside faced by major stock indices.
Garrett recalled the market crash of December 24, 2018. At that time, a client asked him, “Why did the market drop so much today?” Garrett admitted, “I had absolutely no idea.” Even experienced traders find it difficult to judge why the market can suddenly spiral out of control amidst such abrupt sell-offs.
However, historical similarities do not guarantee that the market will repeat itself. In the current correction, the credit market has yet to show significant deterioration, and the Federal Reserve has not signaled a policy pivot. Goldman Sachs believes these differences may be key in determining whether this correction is close to ending.
2018 Recurrence? Goldman Sachs Warns US Stock Correction May Be Far From Over
In the fourth quarter of 2018, US stocks plummeted under the combined pressure of continuous rate hikes by the Federal Reserve, technical breakdowns, and systematic selling, with the S&P 500 index dropping nearly 20% from its peak and bottoming out just before Christmas.
Goldman Sachs compares the declines of major indices since their highs on October 6 with their performance during the same period in 2018. As of Thursday’s close, the S&P 500 has completed 42% of the 2018 decline, the Nasdaq 100 is at 69%, while the Russell 2000 is at just 24%.
If the remaining decline from 2018 is mapped onto the current cycle, Goldman Sachs’ models indicate that major indices could face further correction. Among them, the S&P 500 has not yet finished the corresponding historical decline, suggesting that downside risks have not been fully released.
In terms of timing, it took the S&P 500 65 trading days to fall from its interim high to the ultimate bottom in 2018. As of Friday, the current correction has lasted about 33 trading days. If following a similar trajectory, a market bottom may not be seen until the first full trading week of January next year.

Credit Market Response is Lagging; Fed Has Not Signaled a Pivot
Compared to 2018, current credit market pressures are clearly milder. Goldman Sachs data shows that investment-grade credit spreads have widened by just 5 basis points from their recent highs, and high-yield spreads by 38 basis points—both significantly lower than during the same period in 2018.
The rate market has also not seen a comparable flight to safety. The current 10-year swap rate has declined by 23 basis points from its recent high, with even smaller movements at the short end. This indicates that the market has not comprehensively repriced economic and policy prospects as it did in 2018.
An important catalyst for the 2018 market reversal was then Fed Chair Powell’s “patience” signal on January 4 of the following year. Currently, however, Goldman Sachs economists still expect the Fed to hike again in March next year, with no policy easing signaled yet. Barclays also points out that investors do not currently see the possibility of the Fed stepping in to “backstop” the market.
Safe-Haven Assets Fail; Panic and Market Divergence Intensify
Traditional safe-haven assets have not played their expected role in the current correction. Since the recent peak, gold has fallen 10.8%, and the yen has weakened about 1% against the US dollar; by contrast, during the same period in 2018, gold rose 5% and the yen appreciated 2.1%. The performance of safe-haven assets is clearly diverging from historical patterns.
Panic levels in the market continue to rise. Goldman Sachs’ volatility team rates current market panic at 9 out of 10; the VIX index has risen to 30.3, not far from the 36.1 peak seen just before Christmas 2018, although the S&P 500’s cumulative decline is still less than half of what it was during that time.
Trading structures are also amplifying market volatility. Goldman Sachs estimates that market makers currently hold a net short Gamma position of about $1 billion, potentially increasing hedge selling when markets decline. Clients have recently begun selling high-premium tail options, reflecting that market participants are adjusting their volatility trading strategies.
Individual stocks and investment portfolios are also showing significant divergence. Nvidia has fallen about 39% since early October, facing significant selling pressure. Of the 2,258 investment baskets tracked by Goldman Sachs, baskets that performed well in the first half of the year have generally retraced in the second half; those that more than doubled in the first half had a median second-half return of around -50%. Previous leading trades are now experiencing concentrated unwinding.
Rebounds May Be Just Breathers; True Market Bottom Yet to Be Confirmed
The market is not without conditions for a short-term rebound. Positions have been largely cleared, panic indicators are near extremes, some clients have begun selling volatility, and the Nasdaq 100 is nearing oversold territory. Additionally, historically, the S&P 500 often saw short-term bounce-backs after breaking below its 200-day moving average, and a shortened trading week due to holidays could also give the market a brief respite.
But short-term rebound signals do not necessarily mean the market has bottomed. Before the true reversal in 2018, credit spreads had widened significantly, and the Fed had signaled a shift in policy stance; neither of these key conditions has occurred so far.
Garrett believes that until there is significant deterioration in the credit market or a change in the Federal Reserve’s policy stance, any rebound is likely to be “borrowed.” Investors still need to wait for clearer signals from credit risk and monetary policy before concluding that this round of correction is truly near its end.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
The script at the end of 2018: The Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates, US stocks plunged 20% from the September highs, forcing the Federal Reserve to "pivot" in January.
Goldman Sachs' head of trading believes the current US stock market is repeating the scenario of late 2018, with monetary tightening and equity market pressure. The Goldman Sachs Financial Conditions Index has tightened by about 8 points in two weeks, reaching the highest level in a year. The selloff has broadened from tech stocks to defensive sectors. Gold and equities are declining simultaneously, possibly indicating investors are selling assets to raise cash, making gold a key indicator for observing liquidity stress.

Anthropic (ANT.US) nearly “broke issue price,” but Claude knocks on the doors of “the highest peak in mathematics”! 17 million lines of Lean code used to write a candidate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis
On November 20th, Eastern Time, on its second day of trading, Anthropic's intraday price dropped to a low of $83.05, just 5 cents above the offering price of $83, and finally closed at $88.91, a decline of 8.50%. On the same day, the company's mathematician Levant Alperg announced on his personal website that he and Claude had found a candidate proof for the Riemann hypothesis, which has puzzled the mathematics community for 167 years, and released about 17 million lines of Lean formalized code.
